Is “Rise of Skywalker” worse than “Last Jedi”? This question has sparked intense debate among Star Wars fans worldwide. With the release of the latest film in the franchise, opinions are divided, and many viewers are questioning whether the final installment of the Skywalker saga lived up to the expectations set by its predecessor. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind this debate and attempt to provide a balanced perspective on the matter.
The first thing to consider when comparing “Rise of Skywalker” to “Last Jedi” is the quality of the storytelling. “Last Jedi,” directed by Rian Johnson, was praised for its bold narrative choices and complex characters. The film introduced new elements to the Star Wars universe, such as the Force’s connection to the galaxy’s past, and received critical acclaim for its innovative approach to the series. On the other hand, “Rise of Skywalker,” directed by J.J. Abrams, has been criticized for its perceived lack of originality and for its attempt to tie up all loose ends in a rushed and unsatisfying manner.
One of the main arguments against “Rise of Skywalker” is the film’s reliance on fan service. Many viewers felt that the movie prioritized pleasing the audience with familiar moments and characters over crafting a compelling story. This approach has led to accusations of laziness and a lack of ambition on the part of the filmmakers. In contrast, “Last Jedi” was celebrated for its willingness to take risks and explore new directions, even if it meant alienating some fans.
Another point of contention is the character development in both films. “Last Jedi” received praise for its portrayal of the main characters, particularly Rey and Kylo Ren. The film delved into the psychological struggles of its characters, providing a deeper understanding of their motivations and backgrounds. However, “Rise of Skywalker” has been criticized for its hasty resolution of these storylines, leaving many fans feeling unsatisfied with the character arcs. The film’s rushed ending has been particularly controversial, as it seemed to ignore the emotional growth and development that had been established in “Last Jedi.”
Moreover, the visual and thematic elements of the films also play a role in the debate. “Last Jedi” was praised for its stunning visuals and ambitious set pieces, which added to the film’s epic scale. The movie also explored themes of power, sacrifice, and the nature of heroism, which resonated with many viewers. In contrast, “Rise of Skywalker” has been criticized for its reliance on CGI and the overuse of fan-favorite scenes from previous films. Some fans argue that the film’s focus on nostalgia detracted from its overall impact and message.
In conclusion, whether “Rise of Skywalker” is worse than “Last Jedi” is a matter of personal opinion. While “Last Jedi” received widespread acclaim for its bold storytelling and character development, “Rise of Skywalker” has been criticized for its reliance on fan service and its rushed resolution of the series’ storylines. Both films have their strengths and weaknesses, and it ultimately comes down to how each viewer interprets and appreciates the Star Wars saga.
